Ranked #1
Ep17 - "The Prom" reunion: Beth Leavel, Brooks Ashmanskas, Christopher Sieber, Caitlin Kinnunen, Isabelle (Izzy) McCalla, Angie Schworer and Michael Potts
Ep17 - "The Prom" reunion: Beth Leavel, Brooks Ashmanskas, Christopher Sieber, Caitlin Kinnunen, Isabelle (Izzy) McCalla, Angie Schworer and Michael Potts
Back together for the first time since The Prom closed, this episode features Beth Leavel, Brooks Ashmanskas, Christophe... Read more
1 Jan 2020
•
1hr 7mins
Ranked #2
Ep15 - Jonathan Groff, if you love her, we support you
Ep15 - Jonathan Groff, if you love her, we support you
Groff grew up Mennonite (aka diet-Amish) and rose to prominence in 2006 for his performance in the lead role of Melchior... Read more
17 Dec 2019
•
54mins
Ranked #3
Ep4 - Christian Borle, you'll be amazed just how far he'll go
Ep4 - Christian Borle, you'll be amazed just how far he'll go
Christian Borle is a two-time Tony Award winner for his roles as Black Stache in Peter and the Starcatcher and as Willia... Read more
8 Aug 2019
•
51mins
Ranked #4
Ep5 - "Into the Woods" in Central Park: Reunion with Jessie Mueller, Chip Zien, Sarah Stiles, and Gideon Glick
Ep5 - "Into the Woods" in Central Park: Reunion with Jessie Mueller, Chip Zien, Sarah Stiles, and Gideon Glick
The hot, nasty, sweaty production that was 2012's Into the Woods in Central Park made way for this special Josh Swallows... Read more
20 Aug 2019
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #5
Ep13 - Jessica Vosk, back to the NJ balloon festival
Ep13 - Jessica Vosk, back to the NJ balloon festival
In partnership with TodayTix, Jessica Vosk was part of our first-ever live event held at WeWork in the Flatiron district... Read more
25 Nov 2019
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #6
Ep3 - George Salazar, Feed me (tots), Seymour
Ep3 - George Salazar, Feed me (tots), Seymour
Could ya be more chill with the tater tots, George? In 2011, George made his Broadway debut singing "Light of the World"... Read more
25 Jul 2019
•
46mins
Ranked #7
Ep16 - Lesli Margherita, the grand-poobah of all theatre
Ep16 - Lesli Margherita, the grand-poobah of all theatre
Recorded the day after Josh received the news that his beloved show, The Prom, was closing, Leslie and Josh lament over ... Read more
23 Dec 2019
•
50mins
Ranked #8
Ep6 - Rachel Bay Jones, all I do is laugh at you
Ep6 - Rachel Bay Jones, all I do is laugh at you
Apparently New York smells like tears before bedtime. At least that's what Josh thinks with this episode's guest, Rachel... Read more
3 Sep 2019
•
51mins
Ranked #9
Ep11 - Andy Karl and Barrett Doss, feel the intensity
Ep11 - Andy Karl and Barrett Doss, feel the intensity
As a mini Groundhog Day reunion of sorts, Josh swallows Andy Karl and Barrett Doss whole.Andy Karl has appeared on Broad... Read more
5 Nov 2019
•
51mins
Ranked #10
Ep18 - Ali Stroker, will you Fedex me a grilled cheese, please?
Ep18 - Ali Stroker, will you Fedex me a grilled cheese, please?
Ali Stroker just made history as the first person in a wheelchair to win a Tony Award, and is currently starring in the ... Read more
15 Jan 2020
•
1hr 12mins
Ranked #11
Ep14 - Morgan James, tears before bedtime
Ep14 - Morgan James, tears before bedtime
Morgan James is both an amazing recording artist, being one of the Postmodern Jukebox OG's, and a phenomenal Broadway ac... Read more
3 Dec 2019
•
1hr 3mins
Ranked #12
Ep10 - Alex Wyse, it's not my fault you look like a pillow
Ep10 - Alex Wyse, it's not my fault you look like a pillow
Growing up in Cleveland, Ohio, he made his way to Broadway to do many things, most of which include joking about Beth Le... Read more
22 Oct 2019
•
1hr 3mins
Ranked #13
Ep12 - NY City Center's EVITA creative team: Sammi Cannold, Emily Maltby, Valeria Solomonoff, and Rebecca Aparicio
Ep12 - NY City Center's EVITA creative team: Sammi Cannold, Emily Maltby, Valeria Solomonoff, and Rebecca Aparicio
Getting the history lesson he never bargained for, Josh sits down with the creative team from NY City Center's upcoming ... Read more
19 Nov 2019
•
52mins
Ranked #14
Ep7 - Jay Armstrong Johnson, the little bouncing gay ball
Ep7 - Jay Armstrong Johnson, the little bouncing gay ball
Josh has known Jay Armstrong Johnson since they were in high school -- Jay is currently starring Raoul in as in Phantom.... Read more
10 Sep 2019
•
43mins
Ranked #15
Ep8 - Carolee Carmello, Mr. Stone to see you now
Ep8 - Carolee Carmello, Mr. Stone to see you now
Taking the title role in Hello Dolly! in the national tour, this 3-time Tony nominated actress made her Broadway debut i... Read more
24 Sep 2019
•
55mins
Ranked #16
Ep9 - Lisa Lampanelli, I'm into bi-conversion therapy
Ep9 - Lisa Lampanelli, I'm into bi-conversion therapy
Lisa Lampanelli is a former stand-up comedian, actress and insult comic. Much of her material is racy... and this episod... Read more
8 Oct 2019
•
1hr
Ranked #17
Happy holidays, everyone!
Happy holidays, everyone!
2019 has been a great year! Or has it? Who are we to judge? Turn to that person next to you, give them a great big hug (... Read more
25 Dec 2019
•
4mins
Ranked #18
Ep24 - Beth Leavel, it's roaches! Welcome to New York!
Ep24 - Beth Leavel, it's roaches! Welcome to New York!
Beth Leavel is a Tony Award-winning actress and singer who was most recently seen on stage with Josh in The Prom. A nati... Read more
8 Apr 2020
•
47mins
Ranked #19
Ep23 - Caitlin Kinnunen & Izzy McCalla, he's got to pitch in and put on his royal nappies!
Ep23 - Caitlin Kinnunen & Izzy McCalla, he's got to pitch in and put on his royal nappies!
Sometimes you just have to sit back, relax, and listen to 3 good friends do their thing. Tony nominee Caitlin Kinnunen m... Read more
24 Mar 2020
•
1hr 3mins
Ranked #20
Ep22 - Annaleigh Ashford, don't get your Woody dirty
Ep22 - Annaleigh Ashford, don't get your Woody dirty
Annaleigh Ashford won the Tony Award, Drama Desk Award, and Outer Critics Circle Award for her portrayal of Essie in You... Read more
11 Mar 2020
•
1hr 6mins