Cover image of Nightmare Next Door

Nightmare Next Door

Nightmare Next Door is a true crime show that peels back the peaceful facade of small town America and exposes the dark secrets hidden behind its white-washed picket fences. Nightmare Next Door, the o... Read more

Warning: This podcast data isn't working.

This means that the episode rankings aren't working properly. Please revisit us at a later time to get the best episodes of this podcast!

Ranked #1

Podcast cover

What to Listen to Next: Disappeared

What to Listen to Next: Disappeared

If you enjoyed Nightmare Next Door, you may also like the new season of ID's Disappeared podcast. Listen to The Long Way... Read more

4 Jun 2023

41mins

Ranked #2

Podcast cover

Devil in the Desert

Devil in the Desert

When single gal Adele Curtis meets a terrible end in her Phoenix rental property, detectives delve into a series of susp... Read more

5 May 2023

40mins

Similar Podcasts

Ranked #3

Podcast cover

Innocence Lost

Innocence Lost

In the quaint city of Portage, Indiana, everyone starts pointing fingers when eight-year-old Sarah Paulsen is brutally m... Read more

28 Apr 2023

41mins

Ranked #4

Podcast cover

Last Call

Last Call

In late 2007, Jasper, Texas, native Martin Byerly disappears without a trace. Police look into the 58-year-old ladies' m... Read more

21 Apr 2023

41mins

Most Popular Podcasts

Ranked #5

Podcast cover

Deadly Intentions

Deadly Intentions

A tight-knit community is stunned when the body of Cynthia Epps is found stuffed into a cabinet in her Buffalo, NY, neig... Read more

14 Apr 2023

41mins

Ranked #6

Podcast cover

Taste of Murder

Taste of Murder

When a sip from the office water cooler turns deadly for secretary Julie Williams, detectives are stumped. Who could hav... Read more

7 Apr 2023

40mins

Ranked #7

Podcast cover

Wrong Way Home

Wrong Way Home

When 12-year-old Michelle Winter goes missing without a trace, her family doesn't have a clue as to who could have whisk... Read more

31 Mar 2023

40mins

Ranked #8

Podcast cover

Prescription for Murder

Prescription for Murder

On April 15, 2004, residents of Riverton, WY, are worried about more than the IRS after the brutal murder of prison nurs... Read more

24 Mar 2023

40mins

Ranked #9

Podcast cover

Dead of Night

Dead of Night

When beloved store manager Mary Peterson is found stabbed to death in her bed, storm clouds brew over sunny Lakeland, Fl... Read more

17 Mar 2023

40mins

Ranked #10

Podcast cover

Murder on the Menu

Murder on the Menu

When friendly cashier Tammy Petrin is found shot execution style at the local burger joint, the town of Woonsocket's in ... Read more

10 Mar 2023

41mins

“Podium: AI tools for podcasters. Generate show notes, transcripts, highlight clips, and more with AI. Try it today at https://podium.page”