Ranked #1
Wacko Waco Part I
Wacko Waco Part I
In part one of this episode we discuss events leading up to the 1993 ATF raid on a religious faction known as The Branch... Read more
7 May 2020
•
1hr 12mins
Ranked #2
The Murder of Hannah Wilson
The Murder of Hannah Wilson
We discuss the murder of 22-year-old Indiana University senior Hanna Wilson and how her death might be connected to othe... Read more
8 Feb 2018
•
1hr 24mins
Ranked #3
Betty Broderick's American Cream Pie (re-release)
Betty Broderick's American Cream Pie (re-release)
From the 2018 archives: You've probably heard this story, but this episode is a good one... Betty Broderick meets her fu... Read more
20 Feb 2020
•
1hr 26mins
Ranked #4
How Many Assault Rifles Does It Take?
How Many Assault Rifles Does It Take?
1996, three bodies are discovered in a truck on a rural county road riddled with bullets. Just how many suspects own the... Read more
10 Jan 2019
•
1hr 3mins
Ranked #5
Richmond Hill Explosion Part II
Richmond Hill Explosion Part II
Listen to the investigation, the prosecution, and the fate of the criminals responsible for the explosion and death of o... Read more
16 Jan 2018
•
56mins
Ranked #6
Sarah Jo Pender, The Female Charles Manson
Sarah Jo Pender, The Female Charles Manson
Why would prosecutes refer to Sarah as the "Female Charles Manson?" She was convicted along with her former boyfriend of... Read more
20 Jan 2018
•
1hr 7mins
Ranked #7
Herb Baumeister: As We Know Him
Herb Baumeister: As We Know Him
Herbert Baumeister (a.k.a. "The I-70 Strangler") was an alleged serial killer from Westfield, Indiana. Authorities belie... Read more
1 Feb 2018
•
1hr 25mins
Ranked #8
Central State Hospital for the Insane
Central State Hospital for the Insane
Indiana Hospital for the Insane opened in 1848 after the first five patients were admitted into the sprawling 160-acre p... Read more
17 Oct 2019
•
56mins
Ranked #9
Our's Is The One True Way
Our's Is The One True Way
If you were in a doomsday cult, would you be able to recognize it? In part I of this episode we talk about a UFO cult th... Read more
12 Dec 2019
•
1hr 7mins
Ranked #10
Dr. Helene Knabe Just Wanted to be a Doctor
Dr. Helene Knabe Just Wanted to be a Doctor
Dr. Helene Knabe immigrated from Germany to become one of two female physicians to graduate from the co-educational Medi... Read more
22 Nov 2018
•
58mins
Ranked #11
The Killer Claypool Hotel
The Killer Claypool Hotel
Two women are murdered at the Claypool Hotel in downtown Indianapolis, will police be able to solve the crimes, or do my... Read more
24 Jan 2019
•
54mins
Ranked #12
Disgraced State Trooper Prick Jerry
Disgraced State Trooper Prick Jerry
On March 23rd, 1984 a State Trooper visits the home of his ex-wife in Duggar, Indiana. The events that unfolded next wou... Read more
12 Apr 2018
•
1hr 7mins
Ranked #13
Kelly Cockblock and the Tale of Exotic Meats
Kelly Cockblock and the Tale of Exotic Meats
A missing persons case in Iron River, Michigan calls on a local Police Chief to choose between her job or catching a kil... Read more
26 Jul 2018
•
1hr 31mins
Ranked #14
Ashley Morris Mullis and the Missing
Ashley Morris Mullis and the Missing
A listener suggested case about the disappearance of a young woman that leads to many other missing and unsolved murder ... Read more
25 Jul 2019
•
1hr 15mins
Ranked #15
The Heartless Killer: Charlie Brandt
The Heartless Killer: Charlie Brandt
For 13-year-old Charlie Brandt, his killing spree ended as quickly as it started in Fort Wayne, Indiana in the early 197... Read more
11 Jul 2019
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #16
Belle Gunness Among Us
Belle Gunness Among Us
Belle Gunness lured dozens of men to her La Porte, Indiana farm in the early 1900's promising companionship and good foo... Read more
14 Mar 2019
•
1hr 5mins
Ranked #17
Never Date a Peterson
Never Date a Peterson
The horrify reality is that no woman is safe around a Peterson… Wild speculation abounds concerning the fate of Drew Pet... Read more
21 Feb 2019
•
1hr 8mins
Ranked #18
The Proof is in the Pudding
The Proof is in the Pudding
Tami Duvall thinks that her cooking is just to die for and when two men in her life present her with the possibility of ... Read more
31 Jan 2019
•
58mins
Ranked #19
Loveless Love Letters Part I
Loveless Love Letters Part I
We discuss how teenage rage, drama, and jealousy in the form of harmless little notes slowly take over the lives of thre... Read more
19 Sep 2019
•
1hr 4mins
Ranked #20
International Family Garbage
International Family Garbage
In part II we discuss a sex cult currently known as The Family International that originated in California in the late 1... Read more
19 Dec 2019
•
46mins