Ranked #1
Murdery Teens & a Giant Pizza Mistake
Murdery Teens & a Giant Pizza Mistake
Today we share cases of teens who murdered: The Twilight Killers and Charlie Starkweather & Caril FugateSupport the ... Read more
2 Oct 2019
•
55mins
Ranked #2
4: BONUS EPISODE! Cruise Ship Crimes & 1-800-MERMAIDS
4: BONUS EPISODE! Cruise Ship Crimes & 1-800-MERMAIDS
Today we share the cruise ship stories of missing Rebecca Coriam and the disappearance of George Smith.Support the show
17 Jul 2019
•
1hr 1min
Similar Podcasts
Murder In Alliance
Murder, She Told
MURDERISH
Murderous Minors
Southern Fried True Crime
Least of These
Crime Salad
Big Mad True Crime
The Vanished Podcast
Morbidology
Going West: True Crime
The Generation Why Podcast
Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast
Trace Evidence
Obscura: A True Crime Podcast
Ranked #3
The Murders Behind Famous Scary Movies
The Murders Behind Famous Scary Movies
Today we share murders that later inspired Blockbuster scary movies.Support the show
18 Sep 2019
•
52mins
Ranked #4
Celebrity Crimes & Christmas Beer
Celebrity Crimes & Christmas Beer
Today, we're talking about crimes involving celebrities. Sarah talks about the case of model and prosector Iana Kasian. ... Read more
4 Dec 2019
•
58mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
Thanksgiving Special | Cases from Home
Thanksgiving Special | Cases from Home
Happy Thanksgiving! In today's episode, we have a SURPRISE for you. Sarah shares the story of Diane Downs in Eugene, Ore... Read more
27 Nov 2019
•
1hr 15mins
Ranked #6
Toxic Relationships & Alligator Pears
Toxic Relationships & Alligator Pears
Sarah & Caitlin are talking about domestic abuse cases this week. Sarah dives into the case of Charlotte Rooks, then... Read more
5 Feb 2020
•
58mins
Ranked #7
BFF Murders & A Rapture Announcement
BFF Murders & A Rapture Announcement
We're talking about BFF's who murder each other. Caitlin tells us the tragic death of Cynthia Hoffman, then Sarah shares... Read more
22 Jan 2020
•
57mins
Ranked #8
Colony Tales & Clean Up On Aisle-Caitlin
Colony Tales & Clean Up On Aisle-Caitlin
We're taking it way back to the Colonies. Caitlin shares strange laws and punishments in Colonial America, then Sarah ta... Read more
20 Nov 2019
•
49mins
Ranked #9
Missing Persons and Accidental Fire Alarm Pulling
Missing Persons and Accidental Fire Alarm Pulling
Today we share the missing persons cases of Emma Fillipoff and Lars Mittank.Support the show
14 Aug 2019
•
1hr 2mins
Ranked #10
Cults are Just Clubs Taken Too Far
Cults are Just Clubs Taken Too Far
Today we share two cults: The massive colony of Jonestown and the tragic tale of The Order of the Solar Temple.Support t... Read more
17 Jul 2019
•
1hr 25mins
Ranked #11
Women Who Kill & a Victorian Family Secret
Women Who Kill & a Victorian Family Secret
Today we share the women murderer stories of Katherine Knight and Lillian Strang.Support the show
4 Sep 2019
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #12
Kidnapping Survivors & Caitlin Demotes Sarah
Kidnapping Survivors & Caitlin Demotes Sarah
Today, we're sharing stories of people who were kidnapped and SURVIVE! Sarah shares the story of Nguyen Van, a survivor ... Read more
18 Dec 2019
•
1hr 10mins
Ranked #13
Unbelievable Cases & Y'all Need Sarah's Obsession
Unbelievable Cases & Y'all Need Sarah's Obsession
We're covering stories that are so crazy, they sound made-up. First (big trigger warning), Caitlin shares the brutal kid... Read more
26 Feb 2020
•
1hr 6mins
Ranked #14
The Year of the Rat & Oral Clickbait
The Year of the Rat & Oral Clickbait
Happy NEW YEAR! It's The Year of the Rat. Sarah tells us the story of the newlywed murder of Robert Curley. Then, Caitli... Read more
1 Jan 2020
•
1hr 8mins
Ranked #15
Snow Related Crime & Butts. So Many Butts
Snow Related Crime & Butts. So Many Butts
In today's episode, Caitlin shares a group of serial killers from Snowtown, Australia. Then, Sarah shares the mysterious... Read more
11 Dec 2019
•
58mins
Ranked #16
Survival Against All Odds & Shandy Shenanigans
Survival Against All Odds & Shandy Shenanigans
Today we share the survival stories of Dan Zapp, Danielle MacGuire, and Teri Jendusa-Nicolai.Support the show
21 Aug 2019
•
58mins
Ranked #17
Unusual Weapons of Choice & Woke Dan
Unusual Weapons of Choice & Woke Dan
Today we share unusual weapons of choice - The murders of Dwayne Ball an Georgi Markov.Support the show
11 Sep 2019
•
50mins
Ranked #18
Listener Stories & Caitlin's Bathroom Secret
Listener Stories & Caitlin's Bathroom Secret
We're covering two cases, in depth, that YOU suggested! First, Sarah talks about the Pizza Shop murder of of Hal Sasko, ... Read more
12 Feb 2020
•
1hr
Ranked #19
A Christmas Special: Wrongful Convictions
A Christmas Special: Wrongful Convictions
Merry Christmas! By popular demand, we're sharing cases of wrongful convictions. Sarah starts by sharing the injustice o... Read more
25 Dec 2019
•
1hr 2mins
