Rank #1: 86: The Haunted Doll Market and 420 Zodiac
You might need your EMF readers for this one because we've got two intense stories today. Em brings us the incredibly well-documented and terrifying (we mean beautiful) tale of Harold the doll while Christine tackles the freaking Zodiac Killer. Don't worry, our EMF definitely WASN'T GOING B*****T DURING RECORDING. We're fine. We think. We've also discovered we're unwittingly part of the haunted doll market and Harold might have overfilled Christine's wine glass... and that's why we drink! Please consider supporting the companies that support us! Get 500 high-quality business cards for just $9.99 from Vista Print by going to www.vistaprint.com and using promo code DRINK Get a free trial membership of Beach Body On Demand when you text DRINK to 303030 Get $5 off your first month of Chegg Study when you go to www.chegg.com/drink and enter promo code DRINK Get your own 11x14 Canvas People print for free (just pay shipping and handling) when you text DRINK to 484848
Rank #2: 56: Hell’s Carpet and a McDonald’s Airbnb
Welcome to episode 56, featuring a surprise ghost story from Em’s stepmom! Oh, and a full episode of creepy. Em covers the notorious Enfield Haunting, which inspired the Conjuring 2 and features a lot of walking furniture. By the way, Em’s source was most definitely NOT a Korean Teen Pop Sensation Blog. Just sayin’. Meanwhile, Christine covers the murders of the McStay family, who vanished near the Mexican border and resurfaced in shallow graves in the desert three years later. Their deaths remain a mystery to this day. Come meet us at CrimeCon 2018 this May in Nashville, TN! Get a surprise gift from us when using promo code “ATWWD”! https://www.crimecon.com/ Please consider supporting the companies that support us: Visit [www.tryfirstleaf.com/drink](www.tryfirstleaf.com/drink) to get your introductory three-pack of wines for only $15! Visit [www.mylola.com](www.mylola.com) and use promo code DRINK40 when you subscribe for 40% off your first order! Check out Parcast’s [Haunted Places](https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/haunted-places/id1293860614?mt=2) on Apple Podcasts, Google Play, or wherever you listen to podcasts!
Rank #3: 2: Clotheseline Cookies and the Lone Band-Aid
In episode two, Em and Christine discuss the insanely haunted Whaley House in San Diego and the just plain insane serial killer Robert Durst. And that’s why we drink!
Rank #4: 102: Quantum Madness and an Abundance of Icicles
Helicopters are swarming the studio for this one, folks, because we're on a huge conspiracy theory kick this week! Em brings us the first in their two part series on time travel and Project Pegasus! Meanwhile Christine covers the incredibly creepy story of the Weepy-Voiced Killer, Paul Michael Stephani. We're also talking unique Christmas gifts and things we probably shouldn't have googled on airplanes... and that's why we drink! Please consider supporting the companies that support us! Visit Ritual.com/drink to start your Ritual subscription today! Get a 4-week trial, free postage and a digital scale when you go to Stamps.com, click on the microphone at the top of the page and enter code DRINK Try Zip Recruiter for free when you go to ziprecruiter.com/drink Get $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more when you visit article.com/drink
Rank #5: 4: Demon Pigs and a Call from Tamara
In this week’s episode Em and Christine discuss the notorious Amityville Haunting and the unsolved case of the missing Sodder children. Join us for this extra-chilling episode, but be sure to grab your wine and milkshakes first - you’re gonna need them!
Rank #6: 79: A Demonic Cold Sore and the World's Smallest Violin
Spoiler alert: We survived Christine's Vegas Bachelorette (despite the waiver we signed at Zak Bagan's Haunted Museum)! Today Christine covers the brutal attack of Mary Vincent and Em discusses Peggy the haunted doll WHO WE TALKED TO...and that's why we drink! Visit HIMS.com/ATWWD for a trial month of Hims for only $5! Visit www.tryfirstleaf.com/drink to get your introductory three-pack of wines for only $15! Skillshare is giving our listeners a one-month free trial of unlimited access to over 17,000 classes. Go to www.skillshare.com slash DRINK to start your free month today!
Rank #7: 3: Paranormal Bitchslaps and the Body Examiners
Get your drinks ready. In episode 3 Em talks about a poltergeist legend from Southern folklore, the Bell Witch Haunting. Christine discusses the infamous unsolved case of the Black Dahlia murder.
Rank #8: 94: Cocoa Pebbles County and the Cannibal Cafe
Buckle up, everyone! We've got an extra dark episode for you this week. Em covers the horrific events that happened during the operation of the Byberry Mental Hospital in Philadelphia and the paranormal occurrences it's created, while Christine serves up (it's a pun, you'll see) the story of German cannibal (too much?) Armin Meiwes. We also recap our East Coast tour and describe Christine's childhood home at length - don't worry there are a lot of graves involved... and that's why we drink! Please consider supporting the companies that support us! Try Zip Recruiter for free when you go to ziprecruiter.com/drink Get an exclusive intro offer from First Leaf that includes 3 bottles of wine for only $15, plus free shipping! Go to tryfirstleaf.com/drink Get $20 off your first Simple Contacts order when you go to simplecontacts.com/drink20 or enter DRINK20 at check out Try a free trial membership of Beach Body On Demand when you text DRINK to 303030
Rank #9: 103: Martian Beer Pong and Sweat Glands of the Hand
Guys. Our heads hurt. We’re time traveling again this week for Em’s second part in their series on Project Pegasus and our minds are sufficiently blown. Then things get dark real quick when Christine covers the story of the Bike Path Rapist, Altemio Sanchez. And we might be a little more telepathic than usual this week… and that’s why we drink! Please consider supporting the companies that support us! Get 15% off your first Thirdlove purchase when you go to third love.com/drink For a total of $80 off your first month of Hello Fresh orders, go to hellofresh.com/drink80 and enter code DRINK80 Get 2 months of Skillshare for free when you go to skillshare.com/drink2 Start your free wedding website and get $50 off your registry, go to zola.com/drink
Rank #10: 113: Millennial Pink and Spanish Moss Red Bug Crayons
Cover those ankles, ladies! Because you just might end up in St. Augustine's Old Jail! This week we're bringing you the haunted happenings of the old timey jail that is now Flagler College and the wild ride that is the story of Diane Downs. We also dive into the nuances of surrogate Austrian weddings... and that's why we drink! Please consider supporting the companies that support us! Get 10% off your first 3 months of Ritual when you go to ritual.com/drink Get 15% off your purchase of $100 or more go to modcloth.com and enter code WHY at checkout Get $10 off your first Instacart order when you go to instacart.com or download the mobile app and enter code DRINK at checkout Get $10 off your first FabFitFun box when you go to fabfitfun.com and use our code DRINK
Rank #11: 61: A Human Lazy Susan and the Bloody Brunch
Listen. Are you ready for Em’s story? We're pretty sure you're not, but we’ll tell you anyway. It’s the Squirrel Cage Jail of Pottawattamie County in Council Bluffs, Iowa. Christine was SO ready, she kinda-sorta fell asleep during it, but only because wine. Once Christine wakes up, she covers the krazy story of Leonarda Cianciulli, who fed her favorite son some…questionable…tea cakes. Go to [DAILY-HARVEST.COM](DAILY-HARVEST.COM) and enter promo code DRINK to get three items FREE off your first box! [Night Call](https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/night-call/id1342254154?mt=2) is available now on Apple Podcasts and all other listening destinations. Drop them a line with your night call at 2-4-0-4-6-NIGHT and they'll offer their best advice on life, love, and the coming apocalypse. Visit [Stamps.com/drink](Stamps.com/drink) for a 4-week trial PLUS postage AND a digital scale without longterm commitments.
Rank #12: 31: Pretty Woman Status and the Paranormal Prairie Podcast
In episode 31, we quickly learn that this is not a history podcast, so leave your note-taking at the door. Other notable moments include Christine’s pants falling off, the announcement of our first Facebook Live event, and the monumental discovery that Em’s grandmother published a book on menopause. As far as stories go, Em takes Christine back in time to drink a couple a’ cowboys under the table at the Driskill Hotel, and Christine takes Em back in time to their glory days as Millennial Spiritualists in Southeast Kansas, hanging with America’s first serial killers, the Bloody Benders. And that’s why we drink!
Rank #13: 65: A Gender-Neutral Wolf and Satan’s Center Mouth
Don’t make haste! It’s episode 65, and we’re we’re diving deep into the capture of the Golden State Killer, the murder of Mandy Steingasser, and the 9 Circles of Hell. It’s a choose-your-own-adventure, where Em’s ideal woman has long legs and steak. In this episode, closed cases are solved, and Satan’s got a triple chin. Abandon all hope, u who enter here. Head to squarespace.com/drink for a free trial and use offer code DRINK to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain! Visit www.mylola.com and use promo code DRINK40 when you subscribe for 40% off your first order! For 20% off your purchase, visit TULA.com/drink and enter promo code DRINK at checkout! Havenly - Get 25% off your design package by visiting havenly.com/drink! Go to felixgrayglasses.com/drink to try a pair of Felix Gray glasses today!
Rank #14: 64: Father Bob and Wronger Answers
Em covers the insanely haunted Borley Rectory, which is haunted by a nun, some headless horsemen, and a guy who was not only extra - he was 1863 extra. Meanwhile, Christine goes for a ~theme~ and covers three crazy locked room mysteries. Oh and if you wanna join our mahjong ring, let us know. CrimeCon Meetup: Broadway Brewhouse Midtown on Saturday May 5th at 8pm Central Time
Rank #15: 51: The One Where Ross Gets a Pager and a Moment of Silence for Google
This episode is a doozy. First, we find out Em’s post-life-tiny-house-minimalist agenda when Em covers the South Shield Poltergeist, who tortured an English family the creepiest way possible, with children’s toys. And guys, get ready for a big one - Christine covers our pal Ted Bundy, the charming sociopath who killed AT LEAST 36 people, likely more. This episode is sponsored by: Ziprecruiter - Our listeners can post jobs on ZipRecruiter for free by visiting ZipRecruiter.com/drink! Hello Fresh - Use promo code DRINK30 for $30 off your first week of Hello Fresh! Fabletics - Go to Fabletics.com/drink and get two pairs of leggings for just $24!
Rank #16: 111: A Ghost Tour by Em and a Mother of Pearl Pie Tin
We’re currently sweating and hiding from gators in Florida, so this week we’re coming to you LIVE in our beanies from Portland, Oregon, home of our first standing ovation! (Trust me, we didn’t believe it either.) Listen up as Em covers the dark and twisted history of the infamous Shanghai Tunnels. Meanwhile, Christine covers a story she’s been waiting to tell since episode one… the mystery of skyjacker DB Cooper! We hope you enjoy, and we’ll be back next week. Check out our tour schedule at andthatswhywedrink.com/live! Try Instacart today and get $10 off your first order! Go to instacart.com or download the mobile app and enter promo code DRINK at checkout! Get $80 off your first month of Hello Fresh by going to hellofresh.com/drink80 and enter code DRINK80 Get 15% off your first Thirdlove purchase when you go to third love.com/drink Get a free stock when you sign up with Robinhood! Go to drink.robinhood.com
Rank #17: 15: A Sample of Our Outhouse and Catfished by Lucifer
It’s episode 15, and Em and Christine TOTALLY know that, despite what they may or may not have said in the intro… Listen, this episode is full of bad juju.We chat about the ghosts of St. Alban’s Sanatorium and the disturbing tale of DeeDee & Gypsy Rose Blancharde. There’s a goat-headed man who shoves people down stairs, a haunted bowling alley with a suicide bathroom, and a doctor named BERNARDO FLASTERSTEIN. Honestly, what more do we need to say?
Rank #18: 60: A Brief History of the Indianapolis Urgent Care and A Distorted View of Ice Cream
It’s episode 60, and we’re bringing our A-game, if we do say so ourselves. Em covers the Central Indiana State Hospital for the Insane, a psychiatric treatment hospital in Indianapolis that saw a lot of inhumane treatment, patient suffering, and possibly an emotional support canary. Meanwhile, Christine covers the Yorkshire Ripper, AKA Peter Sutcliffe, AKA Peter Pan, who murdered countless women and also jumped into some graves. By the way, if you’re wondering, Em is not a pier. (or a pee-er.) Come meet us at CrimeCon 2018 this May in Nashville, TN! Get a surprise gift from us when using promo code “ATWWD”! https://www.crimecon.com/ Please consider supporting the companies that support us! Visit HIMS.com/ATWWD for a trial month of Hims for only $5! Hello Fresh - Use promo code DRINK30 for $30 off your first week of Hello Fresh! Visit www.tryfirstleaf.com/drink to get your introductory three-pack of wines for only $15!
Rank #19: 78: Paranormal Toontown and 40,001 Mystery Experiments
Buckets! We learned a new game this week and it involves Space Jam and Kobe. We also snoop out some alien serial killers in the extremely f****d up story of Skinwalker Ranch and cover the disturbing case of the man whose mission it was to save people through their feet, Joseph Kallinger. Christine also does 40 whole pull ups...but only in her lucid dreams. And that's why we drink!
Rank #20: 81: Little Pilgrims and Astrological Issues
Love your hair, hate your guts! It's *just funny* that Em brings back the drunk sorority girl voice but it's fine, we'll talk about it later... This week Em also brings you the mystery of the disappearances at the Flannan Isles Lighthouse in Scotland, and Christine tells the story of Edward, we mean, Charles Cullen, possibly the most prolific serial killer in history. And per Gio's horoscope, he'll see you at the farmer's market, maybe... Love you, mean it! And that's why we drink! -- Go to Liquid-IV.com and enter promo code DRINK for 20% off anything you order on Liquid IV’s website! To save $20 on your contact lenses, PLUS free shipping, go to simplecontacts.com/drink20 or enter DRINK20 at checkout! Visit www.mylola.com and use promo code DRINK40 for 40% off all subscriptions! Use promo code DRINK for $10 off your first FabFitFun box at www.fabfitfun.com! Our listeners can post jobs on ZipRecruiter for free by visiting ZipRecruiter.com/drink!