Rank #1: Episode 124
18 years after a little girl goes missing, new DNA evidence links the crime to a next door neighbor. Stefanie and Matt discuss the narcissistic murderer who never left the neighborhood-- PLUS, Sword and Scale producer Ryan Williams joins the show to reveal an exclusive, unedited 911 call.
Rank #2: Episode 123
Mike Boudet is in studio to comment on the disturbing saga of Adrian Loya: a Star Wars obsessed loser who spent years planning his revenge after a perceived sexual assault.
Rank #3: Episode 46
The Carnation Murders, Part 2. Stefanie and Matt return to discuss the terrible crimes of Joseph McEnroe, along with the unintentionally funny courtroom antics that followed.
Rank #4: Episode 45
The Carnation Murders, Part 1. Hear the origins of what lead to the tragic murder of 6 people, including 2 children. In this episode, Stefanie and Matt listen to the monster who created the monster.
Rank #5: Episode 106
The 'Leaves' Episode. Matt and Stefanie cover the bizarre case of Matthew Hoffman, involving a kidnapping, missing bodies, and a whole lot of leaves.
Rank #6: Episode 98
You may think you know your best friend, but as Stefanie and Matt learn, sometimes the biggest deceits come from the people least expect.
Rank #7: Episode 57
The Facebook Killer, Part 1. Stefanie and Matt discuss the tragic death of Jennifer Alfonso, and what followed when her husband posted the murder photo for friends and family to see.
Rank #8: Episode 93
Randy Stair, Part 1. Stefanie and Matt break down a horrific mass shooting at a supermarket by an angry animator who went by the pseudonym Andrew Blaze.
Rank #9: Episode 62
Mike Boudet returns to discuss the Crazy Catfishing Murders of East Tennessee. Listen to the one episode the CIA does not want you to hear!!
Rank #10: Episode 63
The Macneill Family, Part 1. Stefanie and Matt recount the murder of Michelle Macneill at the hands of her husband, Martin, as a seemingly perfect family falls apart.
Rank #11: Episode 97
A gender reveal party goes horribly wrong when two men start shooting. Adding to the confusion: the mother-to-be was never pregnant. Stefanie and Matt discuss this shocking, still unresolved story.
Rank #12: Episode 114
Matt and Stefanie cover one of the most disgusting Sword and Scales ever (and that's really saying something). This is a story about a boy and his mother...
Rank #13: Episode 33
Luka Magnotta, Part 1. Lynette and Stefanie discuss the lead-up to Luka's horrific acts of violence; including his failed attempts at becoming a Reality TV star, and the weird world of 'reaction videos'.
Rank #14: Episode 78
Stefanie and Matt cover two horrific cases of harm done to children by their absolutely despicable families. This episode is not for the faint of heart.
Rank #15: Episode 79
The Craig's List Killer, Part 1. Stefanie and Matt listen to the police interrogation of a clueless fiancee that ultimately leads to the arrest of one particularly arrogant killer.
Rank #16: Episode 47
The Satanic Panic is the topic of this week's show. Stefanie and Matt look back on some truly bizarre cases involving human sacrifice rituals, as well as the infamous McMartin Preschool Abuse Trial.
Rank #17: Episode 11
This is the episode you've been waiting for. Part one of the death of Morgan Ingram and the bizarre story that evolves after the fact. We're joined by special guest Mayra Martinez.
Rank #18: Episode 107
The disappearance of Jamie Rose Bolin ends as one of the most disturbing and heartbreaking Sword and Scale stories thus far. Stefanie and Matt break it down for ya!
Rank #19: Episode 61
Mike Boudet and Dr. Drew join Stefanie and Matt for a conversation about the devastating death of 9-year-old Connor Verkerke at the hands of 12-year-old Jamarion Lawhorn.
Rank #20: Episode 74
If a horrific murder takes place in your apartment, should the city tear the building down? Stefanie and Matt attempt to answer the question as they break down another very disturbing case.