Ranked #1
Ep 3: The DC Snipers
Ep 3: The DC Snipers
Episode 3 follows the attacks of the DC Snipers. Guest co-host, Arianne Llerena, gives us a first hand account of what i... Read more
18 Dec 2016
•
55mins
Ranked #2
Ep 4: The Horn Family Contract Killings
Ep 4: The Horn Family Contract Killings
In this week's episode, we discuss the murders of Mildred Horn, Trevor Horn, and Janice Saunders, the complicated legacy... Read more
28 Dec 2016
•
48mins
Ranked #3
Ep 7: The Lululemon Murder (with Jacob Griffin)
Ep 7: The Lululemon Murder (with Jacob Griffin)
Guest Host Jacob Griffin joins us to talk about the murder of Jayna Murray, AKA the Lululemon Murder. Join us as we disc... Read more
26 Jan 2017
•
1hr
Ranked #4
Ep 6: Joseph "Joby" Palczynski
Ep 6: Joseph "Joby" Palczynski
Co-host Rebecca Johnson joins Natalie to discuss Joseph Palczynski, the quadruple-murderer, and 97-hour standoff that le... Read more
10 Jan 2017
•
1hr 35mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
Ep 8 Banita Jacks: Possessed by Demons
Ep 8 Banita Jacks: Possessed by Demons
Warning: this is possibly the darkest episode we have ever recorded. Four girls were murdered and their mentally ill mot... Read more
5 Feb 2017
•
56mins
Ranked #6
Ep 10: The Briley Brothers
Ep 10: The Briley Brothers
The Briley Brothers went on a killing spree, were disturbingly violent, and then led a prison break... and you've never ... Read more
27 Mar 2017
•
1hr 29mins
Ranked #7
Ep 11: Leo & Sue (The Home Invasion Episode)
Ep 11: Leo & Sue (The Home Invasion Episode)
Rarely do we have survivors to focus on, but this week we're bringing you the story of Leo and Sue. Dedicated to Abril M... Read more
10 Apr 2017
•
1hr 9mins
Ranked #8
Ep 9: The Family Annihilator
Ep 9: The Family Annihilator
TWO guest hosts join Natalie to talk about our first unsolved episode, the story of Bradford Bishop, The Family Annihila... Read more
27 Feb 2017
•
1hr
Ranked #9
The Dontee Stokes Minisode
The Dontee Stokes Minisode
In our first murder-free-mini-episode we talk about Dontee Stokes, who shot a popular local priest in Baltimore, MD. Is ... Read more
18 Dec 2016
•
30mins
Ranked #10
Ep 5: The Sickles Insanity Defense
Ep 5: The Sickles Insanity Defense
This week we explore first case ever to use the Insanity Defense! Natalie and Michael ramble about infidelity and the do... Read more
4 Jan 2017
•
51mins
