Rank #1: 45- Funky Diva
In a traumatic night of unbelievable circumstance, this week’s My Favorite Murder features the story of Lord Lucan and the mystery of the Summerhill Road Murders.
Rank #2: 76 - My Own Sinkhole
This week, Karen and Georgia discuss the murders of master forger Mark Hofmann and the case of the Central Park 5.
Rank #3: 143 - DeSabotage
Karen and Georgia cover the truth behind poisoned Halloween candy and the murder of Carol Stuart.
Rank #4: 44 - Live from the Chicago Podcast Festival
Karen and Georgia are live at the Chicago Podcast Festival talking about the Fort Worth Three kidnapping and Chicago’s very own John Wayne Gacy.
Rank #5: 163 - Nine Cocaines
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Bob Crane and the Dexter Copycat Killer.
Rank #6: 46 - Skippers Unite!
In a no nonsense episode of My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia discuss the serial killer Leslie Allen Williams and the enigmatic Israel Keyes.
Rank #7: 162 - Prom Queen City
Karen and Georgia cover murderer Mark "Gator" Rogowski and the murder of Jane Bashara.
Rank #8: 144 - Live at the Chevalier Theatre in Medford, MA
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of George Parkman and the Great Molasses Flood of 1919.
Rank #9: 145 - Live at the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles
Karen and Georgia cover the satanic panic of McMartin Pre-School and the Mannequin at the Carnival.
Rank #10: 154 - DNA Dad
Karen and Georgia cover the mysterious death of Thelma Todd and the Footpath Murders.
Rank #11: 111 - Figure It Out Kevin
Karen and Georgia cover the Van Nuys Courthouse shooting and serial killer La Mataviejitas.
Rank #12: 151 - Live at the Queen Elizabeth Theatre in Vancouver
Karen and Georgia cover the Abbotsford Killer and the Salish Sea human foot mystery.
Rank #13: 48 - An Albert Fish Production
On this week's My Favorite Murder (now with a stick of s****y gum!), Karen and Georgia recount the Starved Rock State Park murders and the mysterious ongoing kidnapping case of Sherri Papini.
Rank #14: 146 - Dawna’s Skinny Lighter
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Randy Mock and the Seattle Cyanide Poisonings.
Rank #15: 129 - Coincidence Island
Karen and Georgia cover the Honolulu Strangler and the Galapagos Affair.
Rank #16: 142 - Live at the Durham Performing Arts Center
Karen and Georgia cover the Lawson Family murders and the Bitter Blood murders.
Rank #17: 148 - Live at the Community Center Theater in Sacramento
Karen and Georgia cover attempted assassin Squeaky Fromme and the Lodi Haystack Murder. Plus surprise guest Paul Holes.
Rank #18: 114 - Civic Order
Karen and Georgia cover the Hillside Stranglers and the murder of Dana Bradley.
Rank #19: 152 - Live at the O2 Academy in Glasgow
Karen and Georgia cover the Burke & Hare murders and the Bible John murders.
Rank #20: 158 - Burn Day
Karen and Georgia cover the 3 Billboards murder of Kathy Page and the San Ysidro McDonald's massacre.