Ranked #1
The Final Episode of True Myths, One Lie
The Final Episode of True Myths, One Lie
True Myths, One Lie is coming to an end and Anthony is closing it out with a bang!! In this epic last episode, Anthony i... Read more
26 Apr 2022
•
35mins
Ranked #2
Not Deer, Pukwudgies, and Manananggals ft. Ryan McCauley & Seth Colon
Not Deer, Pukwudgies, and Manananggals ft. Ryan McCauley & Seth Colon
On one of the final episodes of True Myths, One Lie, Anthony brings us a smörgåsbord of stories featuring miscellaneous ... Read more
19 Apr 2022
•
31mins
Similar Podcasts
Chilling Tales for Dark Nights: A Horror Anthology and Scary Stories Series Podcast
Am I the Jerk?
Crime Junkie
SuperMegaCast
Ranked #3
Crawler Confrontations ft. Austin Murphy, Christopher Mennella, and Zach Sicardi
Crawler Confrontations ft. Austin Murphy, Christopher Mennella, and Zach Sicardi
Crawlers are described as humanoid creatures found in the United States and Canada typically in forests. Crawlers are sa... Read more
12 Apr 2022
•
32mins
Ranked #4
Lizard People Are Real ft. Jacob Colon, Ryan Feeney, and Seth Colon
Lizard People Are Real ft. Jacob Colon, Ryan Feeney, and Seth Colon
They are among us. Blood-drinking, flesh-eating, shape-shifting extraterrestrial reptilian humanoids. They are our leade... Read more
5 Apr 2022
•
38mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
The Winged Ones ft. Andrew Heinlein, Christopher Mennella, and Ryan McCauley
The Winged Ones ft. Andrew Heinlein, Christopher Mennella, and Ryan McCauley
Have you heard of The Winged Ones?!? These mysterious humanoid creatures with wings have been known to startle people ne... Read more
29 Mar 2022
•
34mins
Ranked #6
Awkward Alien Encounters ft. Christopher Mennella, Ryan McCauley, and Tom Heinlein
Awkward Alien Encounters ft. Christopher Mennella, Ryan McCauley, and Tom Heinlein
Do you believe in Aliens? This week, long awaited guest host, Ryan McCauley, presents Anthony Mennella, Tom Heinlein, Ch... Read more
22 Mar 2022
•
39mins
Ranked #7
Fan Submitted Stories ft. Austin Murphy and Christopher Mennella
Fan Submitted Stories ft. Austin Murphy and Christopher Mennella
This week Anthony orchestrates the episode with fan submitted stories! From fleeing a humanoid, to getting a thumb chomp... Read more
15 Mar 2022
•
28mins
Ranked #8
1500's Werewolf Horror Stories ft. Ariel Colon, Jacob Colon, and Seth Colon
1500's Werewolf Horror Stories ft. Ariel Colon, Jacob Colon, and Seth Colon
Do you believe in werewolves? According to legends, werewolves are people who morph into vicious, powerful wolves that a... Read more
8 Mar 2022
•
39mins
Ranked #9
Let’s Go Wendigo Hunting ft. Ryan McCauley & Christopher Mennella
Let’s Go Wendigo Hunting ft. Ryan McCauley & Christopher Mennella
According to Algonquin legends, the wendigo haunts the northern forests of the United States and Canada, always looking ... Read more
1 Mar 2022
•
35mins
Ranked #10
The Florida Man ft. Zach Sicardi, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella
The Florida Man ft. Zach Sicardi, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella
We take a break from scary stories this week and lean into comedy as Anthony shares three stories of a Florida Man getti... Read more
22 Feb 2022
•
37mins
