Cover image of I Think Not!

I Think Not!

From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappea... Read more

Ranked #1

Podcast cover

4: The Disappearance of Michelle Whitaker (S1 E4)

4: The Disappearance of Michelle Whitaker (S1 E4)

Michele “Shelli” Whitaker was last seen alive on August 16, 2002 in Spartanburg, South Carolina at a Truck Stops of Amer... Read more

10 Jun 2020

49mins

Ranked #2

Podcast cover

5: The Disappearance of Lee Cutler (S1 E5)

5: The Disappearance of Lee Cutler (S1 E5)

This one truly haunts Patrick's nightmares. Honestly. WHERE. THE HELL. IS HE? 18 Year old Lee Cutler was last seen on O... Read more

17 Jun 2020

50mins

Similar Podcasts

Ranked #3

Podcast cover

3: The Disappearance of Amy St. Laurent (S1 E3)

3: The Disappearance of Amy St. Laurent (S1 E3)

On October 20, 2001, Amy St. Laurent brought her new friend Eric, who was visiting from out of town, to a pool hall in t... Read more

3 Jun 2020

51mins

Ranked #4

Podcast cover

2: The Disappearance of Paige Birgfeld (S1 E2)

2: The Disappearance of Paige Birgfeld (S1 E2)

Paige Birgfeld was a mother of three who was adored by children and by her close knit group of friends. Recently divorce... Read more

27 May 2020

46mins

Most Popular Podcasts

Ranked #5

Podcast cover

9: The Disappearance of The O'Hair Family (S1 E9)

9: The Disappearance of The O'Hair Family (S1 E9)

Madalyn Murray O'Hair was dubbed "The Most Hated Woman in America." She was a staunch Atheist and had been involved in t... Read more

15 Jul 2020

49mins

Ranked #6

Podcast cover

7: The Disappearance of Billy Smolinski (S1 E7)

7: The Disappearance of Billy Smolinski (S1 E7)

August 24th, 2004: 31 year old Billy Smolinski tells a neighbor that he's headed out of town for 3 days. And he is never... Read more

1 Jul 2020

50mins

Ranked #7

Podcast cover

Interview: Rosa Schultz, sister of Roxanne Paltauf

Interview: Rosa Schultz, sister of Roxanne Paltauf

In this interview, Rosa give us new information on her sister's case, shares new evidence that she uncovered herself, an... Read more

30 Dec 2020

21mins

Ranked #8

Podcast cover

23: The Disappearance of the Jamison Family (S2 E10)

23: The Disappearance of the Jamison Family (S2 E10)

They were gone for 8 days before anyone knew they were missing. On October 8, 2009, Bobby, Sherilynn, and their 6 year o... Read more

21 Oct 2020

48mins

Ranked #9

Podcast cover

22: The Disappearance of John Glasgow (S2 E9)

22: The Disappearance of John Glasgow (S2 E9)

Monday, January 28, 2008: 5:15 am. John Glasgow is seen by a neighbor leaving his Little Rock, AR, home in his SUV. A da... Read more

14 Oct 2020

46mins

Ranked #10

Podcast cover

21: The Disappearance of April Pitzer (S2 E8)

21: The Disappearance of April Pitzer (S2 E8)

April Pitzer vanished on June 28, 2004. The former model and mother of 2 was headed home after 6 months in the Mojave De... Read more

7 Oct 2020

44mins

Ranked #11

Podcast cover

19: The Disappearance of Bradyn Fuksa (S2 E6)

19: The Disappearance of Bradyn Fuksa (S2 E6)

22 year old Bradyn Fuksa was last seen by his family and friends on July 14th 2009. His parents couldn’t have known, but... Read more

23 Sep 2020

52mins

Ranked #12

Podcast cover

15: The Disappearance of Tara Grinstead (S2 E2)

15: The Disappearance of Tara Grinstead (S2 E2)

30 year old high school teacher Tara Grinstead vanished from her home in Ocilla, Georgia on October 22, 2005. The circum... Read more

26 Aug 2020

47mins

Ranked #13

Podcast cover

14: The Disappearance of Brittanee Drexel (S2 E1)

14: The Disappearance of Brittanee Drexel (S2 E1)

17 year old Brittanee had asked her parents if she could go to Myrtle beach with friends for spring break. Her parents s... Read more

19 Aug 2020

49mins

Ranked #14

Podcast cover

13: The Disappearance of Royal 'Scoop' Daniel (S1 E13)

13: The Disappearance of Royal 'Scoop' Daniel (S1 E13)

Scoop Daniel was a pillar of the community in Breckenridge, Colorado. HE WAS ALSO A TOTAL DIRT BAG AND WE HATE HIM, but ... Read more

12 Aug 2020

44mins

Ranked #15

Podcast cover

INTERVIEW: "Disappeared" NARRATOR / ANNOUNCER: Christopher Walker!

INTERVIEW: "Disappeared" NARRATOR / ANNOUNCER: Christopher Walker!

EVERYONE BE COOL!! THE NARRATOR / ANNOUNCER IS HERE!! Christopher Walker chats with us about all things Disappeared!!! A... Read more

12 Aug 2020

23mins

Ranked #16

Podcast cover

12: The Disappearance of Bison Dele And Serena Karlan (S1 E12)

12: The Disappearance of Bison Dele And Serena Karlan (S1 E12)

On July 6, 2002, Bison and Serena set sail from Tahiti on Bison's catamaran. Joining them was Bison's brother, Miles.  B... Read more

5 Aug 2020

55mins

Ranked #17

Podcast cover

11: The Disappearance of John Spira (S1 E11)

11: The Disappearance of John Spira (S1 E11)

John Spira, a beloved musician from Chicago, was last seen on February 23rd 2007 at 7pm by his business partner. Accordi... Read more

29 Jul 2020

49mins

Ranked #18

Podcast cover

10: The Disappearance of Rosemary Christensen (S1 E10)

10: The Disappearance of Rosemary Christensen (S1 E10)

In August of 1999, Rosemary Christensen vanished from the Belleair, Florida condo she shared with her husband Robert. Th... Read more

22 Jul 2020

48mins

Ranked #19

Podcast cover

1: The Disappearance of Brandi Wells (S1 E1)

1: The Disappearance of Brandi Wells (S1 E1)

23 year old Brandi Wells was last seen in Longview, Texas on August 3rd, 2006 when she headed out to a nightclub alone. ... Read more

27 May 2020

42mins

Ranked #20

Podcast cover

Obsessed With: Disappeared: Preview

Obsessed With: Disappeared: Preview

Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished re... Read more

13 May 2020

2mins

“Podium: AI tools for podcasters. Generate show notes, transcripts, highlight clips, and more with AI. Try it today at https://podium.page”