Ranked #1
22. The One with the Santa Fe Prison Riot
22. The One with the Santa Fe Prison Riot
Murder and torture and dismemberment, oh my! The Santa Fe prison riot is one of the most violent prison riots in history... Read more
11 Feb 2020
•
46mins
Ranked #2
23. The One with Ashley Benson and Two Chris Yoons
23. The One with Ashley Benson and Two Chris Yoons
No, not the Ashley Benson from Pretty Little Liars. We have a story full of mistaken identities, murder, and too many co... Read more
16 Feb 2020
•
44mins
Similar Podcasts
Ranked #3
28. The One with the Demon House
28. The One with the Demon House
Breaking up your COVID-19 boredom with some hauntings, exorcism, and a ton of demons. Also known as “The 200 Demons Hous... Read more
24 Mar 2020
•
51mins
Ranked #4
21. The One with Jodi Arias’ New ‘Do
21. The One with Jodi Arias’ New ‘Do
Change your hair, change your life, right? We should’ve know Jodi Arias was up to no good when she showed up randomly as... Read more
3 Feb 2020
•
59mins
Ranked #5
24. The One Where Nathaniel Bar-Jonah Should Eat a Snickers
24. The One Where Nathaniel Bar-Jonah Should Eat a Snickers
BYOBurgers to cookouts from here on out! Convicted child molester, possible serial killer, maybe a cannibal? Basically, ... Read more
24 Feb 2020
•
37mins
Ranked #6
26. The One with Daphne Wright’s “Hacked” Crime Scene
26. The One with Daphne Wright’s “Hacked” Crime Scene
What do you get with an electric chainsaw and some blue paint? Basically the worst crime scene cover up ever. Dubbed a “... Read more
9 Mar 2020
•
45mins
Ranked #7
27. The One Where Mary Vincent Fights Like Hell
27. The One Where Mary Vincent Fights Like Hell
Need a break from the Coronavirus stress? We’re bringing you zero peace of mind with the most stressful (but amazing) su... Read more
13 Mar 2020
•
32mins
Ranked #8
30. The One with Cranky, Crazy Amy Bishop
30. The One with Cranky, Crazy Amy Bishop
Don’t call her crazy though! Amy Bishop literally (and allegedly) got away with murder as a teenager, and let’s just say... Read more
8 Apr 2020
•
37mins
Ranked #9
9. The One with the Alexander Family's Ick Factor
9. The One with the Alexander Family's Ick Factor
This one is going to make you feel like showering with a wire brush afterwards to get rid of that icky feeling. The Ale... Read more
7 Dec 2019
•
24mins
Ranked #10
29. The Attempted Assassination of Ronald Reagan
29. The Attempted Assassination of Ronald Reagan
History class is now in session! Since the kids are out of school, we’re taking over as your humble instructors today an... Read more
1 Apr 2020
•
30mins
Ranked #11
25. The One with the Greyhound Bus Beheading
25. The One with the Greyhound Bus Beheading
If we’ve learned anything, it’s that you’re not yourself when you’re hungry and off your meds. Vince Li proved bus rage ... Read more
5 Mar 2020
•
27mins
Ranked #12
36. The One with the Au Pair
36. The One with the Au Pair
Sophie Lionnet thought she’d found the ideal job when she moved from France and became a live-in nanny to London couple ... Read more
29 May 2020
•
43mins
Ranked #13
35. The One with the Turpin House of Horrors
35. The One with the Turpin House of Horrors
David and Louise Turpin seemed like somewhat odd parents, but no one could have guessed they were actually holding their... Read more
23 May 2020
•
30mins
Ranked #14
34. The One with the “Slave Master” Serial Killer
34. The One with the “Slave Master” Serial Killer
John Edward Robinson was truly a freak, but not in a good way. Earning his name by luring women into BDSM relations via ... Read more
7 May 2020
•
53mins
Ranked #15
33. The One with Poisonings, Cemeteries, and Hauntings
33. The One with Poisonings, Cemeteries, and Hauntings
What do an old insane asylum and an abandoned playground have in common? A history of poisonings, eerie cemeteries, and ... Read more
30 Apr 2020
•
37mins
Ranked #16
32. The One with the Ultimate Catfish
32. The One with the Ultimate Catfish
Disgruntled ex + Tinder + Craigslist = What could go wrong? Michelle Hadley was arrested for planning the rape of her ex... Read more
24 Apr 2020
•
43mins
Ranked #17
31. The One with Suspected Serial Killer Herb Baumeister
31. The One with Suspected Serial Killer Herb Baumeister
Wholesome, pure, all-American: Herb Baumeister wanted you to think he was many things, but a suspected serial killer? Kn... Read more
17 Apr 2020
•
41mins
Ranked #18
20. The One Where the Visine Prank Goes Too Far
20. The One Where the Visine Prank Goes Too Far
Just as a general rule of thumb, don't copy Owen Wilson and Vince Vaughn... ever. The Visine Prank is no joke, so the ne... Read more
31 Jan 2020
•
19mins
Ranked #19
19. May Joel Patrick Courtney Choke on a Milkshake
19. May Joel Patrick Courtney Choke on a Milkshake
Our first official listener request! We received a Facebook message asking us to cover the Oregon disappearance and murd... Read more
23 Jan 2020
•
29mins
Ranked #20
18. The One with Bill Bonin’s Stranger Danger Mobile
18. The One with Bill Bonin’s Stranger Danger Mobile
Try typing “Bonin” into your phone and you’ll get autocorrected to abomination... How fortuitous. Bonin, aka The Freeway... Read more
20 Jan 2020
•
1hr 3mins