Ranked #1

Ep 57: Secrets and Sims
Ep 57: Secrets and Sims
In this episode, Paula talks about history's biggest secrets and how they all went terribly wrong while Elaine explores ... Read more
7 Feb 2020
•
1hr 6mins
Ranked #2

22: Missing Bodies and Extra Bodies
22: Missing Bodies and Extra Bodies
What goes better with energy drinks and a cool beach breeze wafting through McCambridge studios than talking about weird... Read more
7 Jun 2019
•
47mins
Ranked #3

24: Prion Pills and Plus Sized Tootsies
24: Prion Pills and Plus Sized Tootsies
Paula explains how there's already tiny zombies among us and gives a disturbing how-to on how zombies could become a rea... Read more
21 Jun 2019
•
56mins
Ranked #4

4: Crop Circles and the Center of Your People Holes
4: Crop Circles and the Center of Your People Holes
In this episode, Elaine and Paula explore crop circle messages from other worldly beings that we're ignoring and why the... Read more
2 Feb 2019
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #5

Ep 61: The Haunted Mormon Empire and Vanishing Into Thin Air
Ep 61: The Haunted Mormon Empire and Vanishing Into Thin Air
In this episode, we suddenly get the urge to Salt Lake City Utah - which, unbeknownst to us until Paula decided to talk ... Read more
6 Mar 2020
•
54mins
Ranked #6

21: Old Toddlers with Linear Splits and Mastering the Evil Eye
21: Old Toddlers with Linear Splits and Mastering the Evil Eye
In this episode, Elaine talks about kids who try to harness their inner WWII jet fighter, and Paula gives you an unneces... Read more
31 May 2019
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #7

30: The One Where We Record at A Haunted Beach House
30: The One Where We Record at A Haunted Beach House
In this episode, Paula and Elaine are both seriously impressed and seriously scared as they record inside their friend's... Read more
2 Aug 2019
•
53mins
Ranked #8

18: Trippin' On Project Blue Balls
18: Trippin' On Project Blue Balls
Episode 18's opening and closing song is by the band Majungas! Check them out at Majungas.comStrap in and try not to get... Read more
15 May 2019
•
53mins
Ranked #9

3: No Good Can Come From Scuttling
3: No Good Can Come From Scuttling
On this episode, Elaine and Paula explore two haunted hotels in California, The Hotel Del Coronado in San Diego and The ... Read more
25 Jan 2019
•
48mins
Ranked #10

11: Specifically Vague Stories of Swallowing Stones and Seared Flesh
11: Specifically Vague Stories of Swallowing Stones and Seared Flesh
In this episode, Paula and Elaine try to explain why people are disappearing in the mountains of Vermont and suddenly go... Read more
22 Mar 2019
•
1hr 5mins
Ranked #11

32: The Legends of August
32: The Legends of August
There's a lot of stuff going down in August! In this episode, Paula says happy birthday to Elaine by telling her the str... Read more
16 Aug 2019
•
57mins
Ranked #12

8: A Collage of Creepy and Our First Ever WTF Challenge
8: A Collage of Creepy and Our First Ever WTF Challenge
In this episode, Elaine and Paula go head-to-head on their first ever creepy story contest where the listeners get to vo... Read more
2 Mar 2019
•
1hr 9mins
Ranked #13

Ep 56: Alien Structures and Snatchin'
Ep 56: Alien Structures and Snatchin'
In this episode, we talk about aliens who build and aliens who snatch celebrities who ARE a snatch. That's right Gwyneth... Read more
31 Jan 2020
•
1hr 7mins
Ranked #14

23: Canned Beef Livers and Pirate Perforated Bowels
23: Canned Beef Livers and Pirate Perforated Bowels
You're just going to have to listen to the episode to fully understand that weird title. Paula and Elaine talk about the... Read more
14 Jun 2019
•
40mins
Ranked #15

Ep 62: Wait Whaaat ... A Spin-Off?
Ep 62: Wait Whaaat ... A Spin-Off?
In this episode, our talk about Scientology and religion led us to talk about the biggest mystery of all - the human mi... Read more
13 Mar 2020
•
52mins
Ranked #16

5: Don't Go Dumpster Diving for the Devil
5: Don't Go Dumpster Diving for the Devil
In this episode, Elaine and Paula discuss the quaint beginnings of the Ouija board and how it has been all downhill to h... Read more
8 Feb 2019
•
1hr 5mins
Ranked #17

Ep 54: Cold and Familiar
Ep 54: Cold and Familiar
Who is the grinning man AKA Indrid Cold and what was his connection to the mothman and what's up with the shiny outfit? ... Read more
17 Jan 2020
•
1hr 16mins
Ranked #18

19: Bucket O' Aliens, Ghosts and Creepy Kids
19: Bucket O' Aliens, Ghosts and Creepy Kids
We didn't mean to run amok on this week's episode but we kind of did - the discussion goes from aliens to ghosts to kids... Read more
17 May 2019
•
41mins
Ranked #19

Ep 64: Creepy Coincidences and Hairy Hands
Ep 64: Creepy Coincidences and Hairy Hands
In light of the COVID19 epidemic, please note that Elaine and Paula took all the proper precautions needed to make this ... Read more
27 Mar 2020
•
57mins
Ranked #20

20: A Soup of Bodies and a Toupee of Horny Possessed Nuns
20: A Soup of Bodies and a Toupee of Horny Possessed Nuns
Paula's back from vacation just in time episode 20, where we talk about why using dead bodies as a foundation for your c... Read more
25 May 2019
•
46mins