Cover image of Suspect Convictions
(713)
Society & Culture
News

Suspect Convictions

Updated 1 day ago

Society & Culture
News
Read more

Barton McNeil discovers his 3-year-old daughter's lifeless body in her bed the morning after breaking up with his girlfriend. McNeil insists that she was murdered by his former girlfriend after pointing to a cut screen in the bedroom window. Police agree a murder has been committed, but arrest him.

Read more

Barton McNeil discovers his 3-year-old daughter's lifeless body in her bed the morning after breaking up with his girlfriend. McNeil insists that she was murdered by his former girlfriend after pointing to a cut screen in the bedroom window. Police agree a murder has been committed, but arrest him.

iTunes Ratings

713 Ratings
Average Ratings
360
157
88
48
60

Like this a lot!

By Adub0602 - Aug 18 2019
Read more
Can’t wait for another season!

One of the best

By The Dog Knows Everything - Jan 16 2019
Read more
Excellent journalism. Period.

iTunes Ratings

713 Ratings
Average Ratings
360
157
88
48
60

Like this a lot!

By Adub0602 - Aug 18 2019
Read more
Can’t wait for another season!

One of the best

By The Dog Knows Everything - Jan 16 2019
Read more
Excellent journalism. Period.
Cover image of Suspect Convictions

Suspect Convictions

Latest release on May 22, 2019

The Best Episodes Ranked Using User Listens

Updated by OwlTail 1 day ago

Rank #1: 02: Jennifer's Tragic Story

Podcast cover
Read more
Before Jennifer’s tragic death, she was living with her mother, stepfather, and newborn baby brother, in Rock Island, Illinois. Jennifer’s mother describes her: “She had brown eyes, brown hair, a pretty smile, teeth like her dad, and she was a little tomboy.” This episode explores Jennifer Ann Lewis, and the home she grew up in. Visit SuspectConvictions.com to learn more.

Jan 09 2017

26mins

Play

Rank #2: 03: A Suspect Conviction

Podcast cover
Read more
About a week after Jennifer was murdered, Scott County prosecutor Bill Davis decided to charge Stanley Liggins with murder. He was one of the only people involved who felt they had enough evidence to charge him, but decided to go ahead with it. Bill Davis says they made the arrest more quickly than they usually would, because of the nature of the crime, and their conclusion that the suspect was a “danger to society.” But what is the evidence? Visit SuspectConvictions.com to learn more.

Jan 09 2017

33mins

Play

Rank #3: 47: Tulsa Time

Podcast cover
Read more

Demarco Carpenter was wrongly convicted of murder. Suspect Convictions investigates this travesty.

SPONSOR:

for 25% off your first order of RX bars visit rxbar.com/suspect and enter the promo code "Suspect" at checkout

Oct 02 2018

46mins

Play

Rank #4: 04: An Accused Killer

Podcast cover
Read more
Who was Stanley Liggins? The man convicted of murdering Jennifer Lewis has a mixed history. In this episode we’re exploring who he was, and the events during his life that shaped him. During hard times, his family said that he was always the one who kept the family laughing. But Stanley also had a history with the law. Visit SuspectConvictions.com to learn more.

Jan 09 2017

30mins

Play

Rank #5: 19: The Wrong Collar

Podcast cover
Read more
Rachel’s Casey’s duplex erupted into flames in July 2001. and her 7-month-old baby died. An arson investigator used a dog to search the fire scene and the dog “alerted” to the possibility that a flammable liquid was used.  But a subsequent laboratory test found the canine was wrong. Despite this, Rachel was prosecuted and found guilty of arson and murder. She had served 14 years of a life sentence when a law professor investigated the case and found the earlier investigation was faulty and relied on “junk science.” Sponsor: RXBar.com/Suspect

Apr 17 2018

34mins

Play

Rank #6: 01: 911- My daughter is dead, send a homicide detective

Podcast cover
Read more
Barton McNeil discovers his 3-year-old daughter's lifeless body in her bed the morning after breaking up with his girlfriend. McNeil insists that she was murdered by his former girlfriend after pointing to a cut screen in the bedroom window. Police agree a murder has been committed, but arrest him.   Sponsors: ZipRecruiter: ZipRecruiter.com/Suspect HelloFresh: HelloFresh.com, and promo code "suspect30"

Oct 30 2017

35mins

Play

Rank #7: 45: Closing Arguments

Podcast cover
Read more

Lawyers make closing arguments in the Stanley Liggins case and Scott Reeder analyzes what the jury knows and doesn't know.

SPONSOR:

stitchfix.com/suspect for 25% off, when you keep all 5 items in your box!

Sep 20 2018

2hr 48mins

Play

Rank #8: 32: A Looming Trial

Podcast cover
Read more

Next week, Stanley Liggins goes on trial for the murder of 9-year-old Jennifer Lewis. The case received international attention during the first season of Suspect Convictions. Scott Reeder and Lacy Scarmana review key clips from the first season and share their thoughts on the case. 

Aug 20 2018

39mins

Play

Rank #9: 05: Furor and a Juror

Podcast cover
Read more
What are the processes that go into ensuring that a jury is impartial? In this episode we look at the jury involved in the Stanley Liggins case, and explore how issues of race may have played into the final decision. While the jury was entirely white, Bill Davis says “You are not entitled to a jury makeup that looks like you. You are entitled to a draw from the general population, where people are not excluded.” Visit SuspectConvictions.com to learn more.

Jan 09 2017

27mins

Play

Rank #10: New show: I, Survivor

Podcast cover
Read more

Women get assaulted. Women get attacked. Women get harassed, manipulated, intimidated, but women are survivors. Time and time again, she persists, even against all odds. Hosts Jenna Brister and Wagatwe Wanjuki share their stories, and those of the men and women who fought back, who won, and who live rising above the trauma of their experiences. Subscribe to I, Survivor today www.wondery.fm/isurvivor

Aug 01 2018

10mins

Play

Rank #11: SEASON 4, Evil in the School Yard, Part II

Podcast cover
Read more

In September of 1990, the burning body of 9-year-old Jennifer Ann Lewis was found abandoned in the playground of an Iowa school yard. Reporter Scott Reeder was one of the first people on the scene that night and he has continued to follow the case for the past 28 years. The man accused of her murder, Stanley Liggins, will be re-tried this month after an appellate court threw out his conviction. Suspect Convictions explains the case to listeners and prepares them for the upcoming trial.

Aug 11 2018

25mins

Play

Rank #12: 15: A 60 Year Wait for Justice

Podcast cover
Read more
Darrel Parker was a 24-year-old newlywed when he was convicted of murdering his wife in Lincoln, Nebraska. He spent the next 60 years fighting to clear his name. Scott Reeder interviews the 86-year-old Parker and takes listeners on a 60-year journey until Parker was able to prove his innocence and receive an apology from the state. Sponsor: Rxbar: rxbar.com/suspect and use the promo code "SUSPECT" at checkout for 25% off.

Feb 19 2018

39mins

Play

Rank #13: 16: Confessions of a Substitute

Podcast cover
Read more
Mary Beth Haglin was a brilliant young teacher, a recipient of a prestigious Fulbright Scholarship and a talented instructor. Then the 23-year-old had a sexual relationship with a 17-year-old student. When they were found out, her life began to unravel. First, she lost her job and then she became a pariah in the community. Next, she became a stripper and acted in porn videos. Now, she faces jail time. We look at Mary Beth’s descent, the decisions she made and ask: Should her mistake be treated bad judgment or criminal conduct? Sponsor: Rxbar: rxbar.com/suspect and use the promo code "SUSPECT" at checkout for 25% off your first order

Mar 05 2018

34mins

Play

Rank #14: 17: Smokescreen

Podcast cover
Read more
Kristine Bunch served 17 years in prison for a crime that never happened. On June 30, 1995, the Indiana trailer where she lived erupted into flames. Her 3-year-old son, Tony, was found dead in his bedroom. Police immediately accused Bunch of arson, which she denied. A laboratory report was altered and based on this altered report she was convicted. Bunch tells the story of how she overcame the false conviction.

Mar 26 2018

1hr 6mins

Play

Rank #15: 02: A window into a murder

Podcast cover
Read more
Did an intruder enter the bedroom of 3-year-old  Christiana McNeil? Suspect Convictions analyses the evidence.   Sponsors: ZipRecruiter: ZipRecruiter.com/Suspect

Nov 06 2017

30mins

Play

Rank #16: 12: A Mysterious Bed Purchase

Podcast cover
Read more
The bed in which Christina McNeil was murdered was later purchased at a thrift store by the same woman who the girl’s father says killed her, a Department of Children and Family services report indicates. That is one of the revelations in this week’s episode of Suspect Convictions. After Barton McNeil was arrested and ultimately convicted of the murder, his brother donated the bed to The Salvation Army. Misook (Nowlin) Wang was doing community service at The Salvation Army at that time, related to a domestic abuse case against her. Wang is said to have bought the bed and gave it to her own daughter to sleep on.

Jan 16 2018

38mins

Play

Rank #17: 20: That Bites

Podcast cover
Read more
Did a faulty forensic technique called “bite mark analysis” send two innocent men to Mississippi’s death row? Scott Reeder examines the issue.   Sponsors: www.ThisSoundsSerious.com

May 01 2018

30mins

Play

Rank #18: 18: Innocent Man Faces Electric Chair

Podcast cover
Read more
Perry Cobb was sentenced to death for a murder he did not commit. Today he holds the record for the person tried the most times for the same murder. He was freed from death row by a young journalist and a new law school graduate, who defied political pressure to testify on Perry’s behalf.

Apr 07 2018

29mins

Play

Rank #19: 03: Vibrators, Accusations and a Little Girl

Podcast cover
Read more
Was Christina McNeil sexually assaulted? Experts disagree. And if such an assault took place, accusations are flying as to who is responsible.   Sponsor: ZipRecruiter.com/Suspect

Nov 13 2017

32mins

Play

Rank #20: 06: The Mind of a Killer

Podcast cover
Read more
There are many uncertainties surrounding the Stanley Liggins case. On this episode, we're looking into the psychology of a murderer, and what is going on in somebody's mind who might do something like this. In addition, we address the difficulties around long-term memory, how memories change and morph over time, and what can and cannot be trusted in a testimonial, even of an eyewitness. Visit SuspectConvictions.com to learn more.

Jan 20 2017

34mins

Play