Cover image of Cathy Cesnik

Cathy Cesnik

11 Podcast Episodes

Latest 24 Sep 2022 | Updated Daily

Episode artwork


Reality Life with Kate Casey

Randy Wilkins, Director The Captain (ESPN), an exploration of the life and Hall of Fame career of New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter. Medium Jonathan Mark discusses the unsolved murders of JonBenet Ramsey and Sister Cathy Cesnik. Reality Life with Kate CaseyPatreon: http://www.patreon.com/katecaseyCameo: https://cameo.com/katecaseyTwitter: https://twitter.com/katecaseyInstagram: http://www.instagram.com/katecaseycaTik Tok: http://www.tiktok.com/itskatecaseyClubhouse: @katecasey Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/113157919338245Amazon.com: www.amazon.com/shop/katecasey Make sure you’re taking advantage of the opportunity to earn something back for all those Pampers you’re going through. Download the Pampers Club app and start turning diapers into rewards.  Earn $5 PampersCash with your first three product scans. Download Pampers Club app today and get access to exclusive Pampers coupons and more!”See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.


5 Aug 2022

Episode artwork

The Case of Candy Montgomery & The Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik

Sinister Sisters

It's a True Crime week, murderinos! In this week's episode, we're on the case of not one but two infamous True Crime stories that have been famously featured in recent streaming series. Lauren starts us off with the case of Candy Montgomery - a woman who murdered her friend, Betty Gore, with an axe in Wylie, TX on Friday the 13th, 1980. You can see the dramatized version of this story in Hulu's "Candy" starring Jessica Biel as Candy AND yet another upcoming series based on the same story - HBO Max "Love and Death" starring Elizabeth Olsen as Candy.Later in the episode, Felicia covers the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik in Baltimore, Maryland. Her body was discovered on January 3, 1970 under mysterious circumstances. While the case has never been officially solved or suspects charged,  the nun may have known too much about the sexual assault on students by two priests at Archbishop Keough High School where she worked. The True Crime tale was explored in Netflix's critically acclaimed "The Keepers" docuseries in 2017.


5 Jul 2022

Similar People

Episode artwork

Let The Women: Gemma Hoskins on the Murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik

True Crime Obsessed

Gemma Hoskins remembers high school fondly, thanks in large part to her favorite teacher Sister Cathy Cesnik. So, when the beloved nun disappeared one November night in 1969 only to eventually be discovered dead in the woods, grief took hold over this ambiguous story for decades. And then, truth-telling around abuse in those hallowed halls merged with Gemma’s outstanding questions. 40 years after the murder, she got to work with the help of a former classmate of hers, and together they’d uncover more about the past than anyone expected. To donate to the Sister Cathy Cesnik Fund for Survivors, visit srcathyfundforsurvivors.org. This episode is part of a ten-part series called Let The Women Do The Work. Join host Gillian Pensavalle as she follows the stories of ten dynamic, inspiring, badass women in true crime. This week's sponsors: Liquid IV - Grab Liquid IV in bulk nationwide at Costco, or you can get 25% off when you go to LiquidIV.com and use the code "Work" at checkout. Billion Dollar Box - Build your own Billion Dollar Box at billiondollarbeauty.com & receive 20% off your entire purchase when you enter code “WORK” at checkout. Athletic Greens - Athletic Greens will give you a FREE one-year supply of immune-supporting Vitamin D AND 5 FREE travel packs with your first purchase. All you have to do is visit athleticgreens.com/WOMEN.


19 May 2022

Episode artwork

Episode 32: Sister Cathy Cesnik

The Midnight Record

In this week's episode, Charlotte brings us the disappearance and death of Sister Catherine Cesnik. Charlotte goes over the details of the unsolved 1969 murder of Sister Cathy, some of the theories surrounding her death, as well as the horrors that went on at her time at Baltimore’s Archbishop Keough High School. Buckle up, it's a wild ride.  SOURCESThe Hippie Catholic YoutubeThe Keepers Documentary NetflixSister Cathy WikipediaJoseph Maskell WikipediaVoxInside BaltimorePopSugarTW: Listener discretion is advised.  Have a personal connection to a true crime story, conspiracy theory or paranormal encounter that you'd like to share with us? Send us an email at themidnightrecord@gmail.com.Instagram: @themidnightrecordTikTok: @themidnightrecordTwitter: @TMRPodMusic by: Nathanael McClure

1hr 24mins

20 Oct 2021

Most Popular

Episode artwork

Episode 3: Sister Cathy Cesnik

Pourly Executed: A True Crime Podcast

Grab a glass and join Olivia & Erin as they dive into the murder case of Sister Cathy Cesnik! The adored nun who was mysteriously murdered after trying to put an end to the rampant sexual abuse her students were experiencing at the hands of their Chaplain, Father Maskell. You'll want to punch so many of these people in the face. Trigger warning: Graphic detailing of child sexual abuse*Formerly known as Murder & Merlot*Follow us on Instagram @pourlyexecutedEmail us your ideas and stories at pourlyexecuted@gmail.comThis story was made possible with the following sources:Netflix's The Keepershttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Catherine_Cesnik

1hr 28mins

28 Sep 2021

Episode artwork

Episode 11: The Murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik

Dark As Hell: A True Crime Podcast

This week on Dark As Hell, I’m telling you a story about a good Catholic schoolgirl -- one so good, she became a nun as a young woman. But this isn’t just the story of Sister Cathy Cesnik; this story also involves many other good Catholic schoolgirls; most who knew and loved Sister Cathy as her students at Archbishop Keough High School in Baltimore, Maryland. This isn’t just a case about a ruthless, senseless murder — it’s about the extensive cover up of this murder, and the 50 years that many Baltimore organizations have spent turning their gaze heavenward when asked why, oh, why have you forsaken Sister Cathy Cesnik? Let's get ready to get Dark As Hell. Keep up with Dark As Hell on social media! Instagram| Twitter | Email: darkashellpodcast@gmail.com--- Support this podcast: https://anchor.fm/maggie-burgess/support

1hr 26mins

17 Aug 2020

Episode artwork

Cathy Cesnik: il mistero di Baltimora

Irrisolti. I misteri del crimine

Perché nel 1969 a Baltimora una suora di soli 26 anni è stata uccisa e il suo corpo buttato in un campo vicino a una discarica? Intrighi religiosi, pedofilia e minacce sono i protagonisti di questa storia quasi incredibile, ma purtroppo, drammaticamente vera.


10 Aug 2020

Episode artwork

TRUE CRIME: Sister Cathy Cesnik

Crackpot Cocktail Hour

In 2016, The Keepers documentary on Netflix ignited a media frenzy into the speculation of Who Killed Sister Cathy Cesnik? Nearly 3 years later and after new DNA testing, follow us down the rabbit hole as we explore what may have happened to the Sister that November night in 1969. Music Courtesy of SoundCloud.org Outro By: https://freesound.org/people/Snapper4298/  Additional music by: https://freesound.org/people/lizziam/ For more information, please for to https://CrackpotCocktailHour.com 

1hr 43mins

30 Oct 2019

Episode artwork

Gemma Hoskins Researcher From "The Keepers" on Netflix Discusses The Murder Of Cathy Cesnik

Marta On The Move Podcast- Hosted by Marta Napoleone Mazzoni

Gemma Hoskins From "The Keepers" on Netflix   This is the lead up to Halloween in which I feature different themes revolving around this holiday. Stories about facing your fears, spooky stories, psychics, magic, murder, and more have been featured, and I could not wait to release this episode. There was once a suggestion on Netflix given to me by a friend, that suggestion was a documentary called “The Keepers”. I had no clue what the show was about, but trusted the source and one weekend while I was ill decided to binge it. I was instantly hooked.   Where do I even start with this? How do I tell you to watch this show without giving too much away? The story is disturbing, but it is an important one to hear. It revolves around a cold case murder that took place 50 years ago in Baltimore, Maryland. It unfolds to reveal a parallel storyline about female students who are now grown up women that attended the Catholic school named Keough and triggered memories of their time at school.   Secrets, murder, rape, and more come to light in this documentary. You won’t believe what you hear, and who was all involved. It is important especially when so many priests and the Arch Diocese are being currently investigated in many cities across the country, and I believe that "The Keepers" had a huge hand in triggering a lot of this. Remember, this was before Spotlight, and I can not imagine the guts it took for these women and men to come forward, face their pasts, and confront their abusers. It is truly horrifying, but it has prompted even some friends that have had similar experiences to speak openly about them, and that is important. I could not wait to release this for the lead up to Halloween especially because Sister  Cathy Cesnick.  IS a Pittsburgh native. She is buried in her hometown of Sharpsburg.   Gemma Hoskins is one of the leading investigators who researched this story. I was honored she took the time to answer my questions about the case, and was very candid about where we are currently in this investigation. Her and friend Abbie Schaub were very brave historians and students of Cathy. They have even been featured on "The View" to talk about the show. Gemma and Abbie spring boarded this investigation, and hopefully with the help of others who have information we will have Justice for Sister Cathy and all the victims of abuse out in the world.   Check out the Justice for Cathy Cesnik and Joyce Malecki Facebook page, and follow along in the events that are unfolding. Topics discussed- - How the investigation started and lead to Gemma and Abbie - How the Netflix show picked up the information and formulated the show. - Who is Brother Bob? Marta and Gemma discuss. - Why the police are finally now more involved in working to solve the case. - Where YOU can take your information if you have leads. - Does Gemma feel as though we are any closer to solving the case? - Were the other nuns involved? - Will there be a season 2 of The Keepers? Sister Cathy Cesnik. Father Maskell. Courtesy of Netflix Gemma and Abbie on The View     The lead up to Halloween ends with our live podcast in Pittsburgh. Don't forget to grab your tickets to True Spooky Stories of Pgh LIVE Podcast on Oct 14th! Free Craft beer! Sponsored by Helicon Brewery and Barebones Productions


23 Sep 2018

Episode artwork

02: Sister Cathy, Part 1 [Netflix's The Keepers]

Foul Play: Crime Series

Was the murder of Sister Cathy to protect the secret of a giant pedophile ring of abuser catholic priests and police officers in Baltimore? Some of this investigation was featured on the Netflix documentary series The Keepers - but here we continue to work on Cathy's case and uncover more of the true events surrounding the abuse and coverup. Join Shane Waters and The Keepers' Gemma Hoskins in this series, along with many of the women and men featured in the the Netflix series. This is an ongoing series.Visit us online at itsfoulplay.com


17 Sep 2018